Your cart

Your cart is empty

Hats Off to the Milliners- Old Photo Album Summer 2020

By Noelle Wiedemer and Arlesa Shephard

[All images courtesy of The Buffalo History Museum - The Howard D. Beach Photography Studio Collection]

Author Jeanine Larmoth describes a hat as, “… a shameless flatterer, calling attention to an escaping curl, a tawny braid; a sprinkling of freckles over a pert nose, directing the eye to what is most unique about a face. Its curves emphasize a shining pair of eyes, a lofty forehead; its deep brim accentuates the pale tint of a cheek, creates an aura of prettiness, and suggests a mystery that awakens curiosity in the onlooker.” Indeed. What better way for a photographer to draw the viewer’s gaze to the lovely face of a woman in a portrait than by having her head adorned with a wide-brimmed, ornately decorated hat?

Millinery fashion during the Edwardian Era (circa 1901-1914) mimicked the opulence of the British monarch for whom the era was named. Feathers and flowers, lace and tulle – almost everything but the kitchen sink was used to top off the head of the modern woman. Plumes known as aigrettes, from the tall spiky feathers from the snowy egret, were common until laws were passed to protect the endangered birds. Ostrich feathers were another of the more popular types of feathers found at this time. Hats, sometimes up to six feet wide, were so large at one point that a yard or two of hair had to be rolled on top of the head in a style known as the pompadour. The hat was then secured with a hat pin which could be as long at 18 inches! 

During the Great War (1914-1918), it was considered unseemly to flaunt one’s wealth. When milliners’ materials were sometimes difficult to obtain or redirected to war manufacturing, self-sacrifice was embraced to show support for the war effort, and the increasing popularity of shorter hair and the automobile gave rise to a demand for smaller brimmed, more head-hugging attire. Austerity measures, however, didn’t completely eliminate the ornate embellishments demanded by the trendy woman.

Various styles are worn in the portraits that follow. The hat known as Gainsborough, or picture, were generally tipped up on one side and were reminiscent of the 18th century hats depicted in the paintings of British artist Thomas Gainsborough. They framed the head and highlighted a woman’s face. A smaller, close-fitting brimless or small, rolled-brimmed hat known as the toque was popular in the early 1900s. It was often ornamented with plumes. Similarly, a turban was a toque-style hat with fabric trimmings twisted or folded about the hat, reflecting an eastern influence. The cloche, which became popular in the 1920s, was a bell-shaped, brimless hat that could have a narrow brim turned downward, typically shorter in the front and slightly longer in the back.

Hats off to the milliners who shamelessly flattered the women of Buffalo a century ago!

There's so much more history in store.

Mrs. Kellogg posed demurely with a wide-brimmed picture hat topped with dozens of silk flowers and an enormous silk ribbon bow. Her hair was worn in the pompadour style underneath. 1908

Mrs. Ida May Hall’s hat sported a rather large-plumed feather, probably from the tail of an ostrich raised specifically to harvest feathers for hats. The sheen on the fabric suggests that it could be velvet, a common material for hats at the time. 1906

Readers may recognize Mrs. Grace Taylor from the cover of our Fall 2018 issue. Her enormous picture hat, which stretches from shoulder to shoulder, was adorned with yards and yards of tulle fabric (a type of netting). What appears to be two ostrich plumes peek over the side. She also wore her hair in the pompadour style. 1904

Readers may recognize Mrs. Grace Taylor from the cover of our Fall 2018 issue. Her enormous picture hat, which stretches from shoulder to shoulder, was adorned with yards and yards of tulle fabric (a type of netting). What appears to be two ostrich plumes peek over the side. She also wore her hair in the pompadour style. 1904

Mrs. E. Thomas posed in her summery lace and eyelet dress. The fashion statement was complete as her head was topped by a lovely straw hat decorated in excess with silk flowers, ribbons and a large bow. 1908

Mrs. Helen Bissell’s ornately beaded dress and lace scarf was complemented by what was possibly a heavily napped beaver fur hat based on the texture. The feathers were possibly dyed and trimmed ostrich with what appears to be a piece of feather boa. 1909

Miss Kathleen Irwin also sported a rather wide-brimmed picture hat with an enormous bow. The hat was possibly made of felt or velvet. 1915

Mrs. Smith’s two-toned picture hat was striking in its modern design. It appears to be straw with part of the hat covered in a silk chiffon or other type of fabric to give it the beautiful two-tone look. 1915

Mrs. John Miller Horton’s hat appears to have a semi-sheer brim with a wire support. The large plumes, as big as her head, appear to be bird of paradise feathers. 1916

E. Brennison wore a brimless hat that appears to be a predecessor to the cloche style which became popular in the 1920s. The white “crown” added dimension to the black straw hat and had a texture that may be feathers — possibly goose or turkey which could be cut and shaped. 1918

Mrs. Myron Hall’s choice was a narrow-brimmed straw hat with a large silk bow and feathers that look like egret. This may have a narrow enough brim to fall into the category of a toque. 1918

Gertrude Ruth Rankine wore a simple picture hat with silk satin ribbon trim. The texture indicates it may have a fabric covering on the brim and crown. 1918

Mrs. A. H. Dolson’s hat followed the design of an early cloche hat. It fit closer to the head possibly thanks to the short hairstyles. 1918

Bessie Wasson sported a descendant of the picture hat. It had a less structured semi-sheer brim. Silk dogwood flowers and a satin ribbon were wrapped around the crown. 1918

Mary Riselay wore a brimless hat that would fall into the category of a toque. It appears to be made of velvet. While the decoration could be ostrich plume, it is more likely a chenille yarn used to imitate a plume. 1918

The wide brimmed hat worn by Mrs. G. E. Robertson is trimmed with a silk satin ribbon and a cluster of small feathers. 1919

Ada Gates’ head was topped with a narrow-brimmed toque, draped in velvet, trimmed in a decorative lace fabric and topped with an ostrich feather. 1919

Mrs. I. Potter’s narrow-brimmed toque or turban was trimmed or wrapped with what appears to be ostrich feathers. 1919

The wide brimmed hat atop Miss E. Thomas appears to be draped in a velvet fabric. The brim was decorated with either an embroidered or applied decoration. 1919

Pauline Stow wore a turban-style hat draped in what looks like a satin brocade on the crown and possibly a textured fabric on the turned up brim. The decoration on the side was likely a metallic narrow lace, yarn or bead trim. 1921

Margaret C. Beach’s velvet picture hat had the typically draped fabric on the crown similar to other hats in these photographs. It appears to be trimmed with ribbon, a silk flower and a feather. Her neck was wrapped in what seems to be a fox collar. 1919

Mrs Edwin G. [Kathryn M.] Ziegeler sported a brimless hat or toque.  Like Miss Brennison’s hat, it would not be a cloche because it has an even edge that does not slant down toward the ears. The hat was completely covered in feathers. 1917

Mary West wore a picture hat covered in what looks like a silk fabric with lace trim on the brim. 1920

About the Author

(obviously we aren’t including one for Noelle, as she is “one of us!”)

Arlesa Shephard, Ph.D, is an Associate Professor in the Fashion and Textile Technology department at Buffalo State College.